Discover 20 Exquisite Dining Experiences in New Buffalo, Michigan

New Buffalo, Michigan, boasts an abundance of delightful dining establishments, catering to the multitude of visitors who are drawn to its breathtaking Lake Michigan beaches and awe-inspiring natural scenery throughout the year.

Situated a mere 90 minutes away from both Chicago and Grand Rapids, this vibrant city in Michigan takes great pride in its diverse array of restaurants, breweries, and wineries. Whether you’re seeking a scrumptious breakfast, a satisfying lunch, or an unforgettable dinner, New Buffalo offers an extensive selection to satisfy every palate. Indulge in an eclectic mix of culinary delights, ranging from comforting soul food to delectable crab legs, alongside an assortment of wine bars and enchanting outdoor patios.

Embark on a gastronomic journey as we present the crème de la crème of dining establishments in New Buffalo, Michigan.

Bentwood Tavern in the Marina Grand Resort
600 W Water St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

Bentwood Tavern in the Marina Grand Resort

From the tantalizing “Sushi Thursday” to the delightful combination of “Tacos and Tequila,” this establishment, encompassing a restaurant and cocktail bar, boasts a diverse and delectable menu. It caters to both early morning cravings and evening desires for a delectable wood-fired pizza. Situated by the water’s edge, it epitomizes the pinnacle of Michigan’s dining experiences and serves as an idyllic setting for a memorable and enjoyable date night.

Brewster’s Italian Cafe
11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

Brewster’s Italian Cafe

Indulge in exquisitely prepared traditional Italian cuisine within the warm embrace of a charming and inviting ambiance. Discover this concealed treasure, graced by amiable personnel, discreetly nestled just off Whittaker Street. Ensure you seize the opportunity to experience their exquisite outdoor seating on a picturesque patio, a truly captivating setting.

Milda’s Corner Market
9901 Town Line Ave, Union Pier, MI 49129

Milda’s Corner Market

Situated in the charming town of Union Pier, this delightful establishment showcases a diverse array of goods sourced from more than 40 countries. Visitors can indulge in a variety of delectable treats such as imported preserves, artisanal chocolates, and enticing confections. Additionally, they can savor the creamy delight of Lithuanian ice cream or sample the flavorsome Koldunai dumplings.

Oink’s Dutch Treat
227 W Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

Oink’s Dutch Treat

Escape the summer heat by indulging in a delectable serving of ice cream or frozen yogurt within a charmingly adorned ice cream parlor, inspired by adorable pig motifs. This delightful establishment, beloved by families and cherished by holidaymakers, offers a splendid outdoor seating arrangement to enhance your experience. Don’t forget to explore the delightful offerings at Oink’s Chocolate, Pig, where you’ll find an array of irresistible confections to satisfy your sweet tooth even further!

Beer Church Brewing Co.
24 S Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

Nestled within a meticulously restored church from the era of the Civil War, Beer Church Brewing elevates the notion of “beer and pizza” to extraordinary heights. Alongside their exquisite, limited-quantity brews, they offer a culinary masterpiece that rivals the finest pizzas found in the city of Chicago. The Pizza Napoletana is an unparalleled delight, exuding remarkable flavors that harmonize flawlessly with their selection of handcrafted beers. This destination is an absolute must-visit for enthusiasts seeking an unforgettable experience.

Staymaker’s Restaurant at the Journeyman’s Distillery
109 Generations Dr, Three Oaks, MI 49128

Situated in the charming vicinity of Three Oaks, in close proximity to New Buffalo, lies a remarkable distillery specializing in organic spirits. Housed within a historic edifice that once served as a corset factory, this establishment stands apart as one of the rare few distilleries in the nation to boast both organic and kosher certifications. With an unwavering commitment to quality, they take pride in their meticulous production process, ensuring that every drop of their spirits is crafted from the very grains to the final glass.

Within the confines of this distillery, one will also discover the delightful culinary haven known as Staymaker’s Restaurant. A visit to this esteemed eatery is a true feast for the senses. The menu, an exquisite amalgamation of flavors, caters to a diverse range of palates. From the tantalizing Idaho Trout adorned with delicate shavings of Portabella mushrooms to the Gluten-free Butternut Squash Soup, which, in my humble opinion, stands unrivaled in its delectable excellence, the gastronomic offerings are nothing short of extraordinary.

Greenbush Brewing
5885 Sawyer Rd, Sawyer, MI — 49125

Greenbush Brewing

I have an equal appreciation for both the delectable beverages and cuisine available at Greenbush Brewing. The menu offers a delightful array of choices, such as the delectable shrimp and grits, as well as an impressive selection of barbecue options, including mouthwatering pulled pork. Rest assured, you can’t make a wrong choice when dining at this establishment.

Jackie’s Café
801 W Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

This trendy café delights its customers with a delectable breakfast experience that combines traditional favorites with a contemporary touch. One of the standout dishes on their menu is the exquisite blueberry French toast, a culinary masterpiece that I can confidently say is the finest I’ve ever had the pleasure of savoring. Additionally, Jackie’s ‘Back Door’ bakery entices visitors with an assortment of delectable treats, irresistible desserts, and convenient take-home meals.

Casey’s New Buffalo
136 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

Indulge in a delectable culinary experience where a rich variety of steaks, tantalizing seafood, and mouthwatering Italian dishes await. Nestled within the walls of a historic two-century-old building, this exquisite establishment features a captivating blend of tradition and modernity. Its art deco bar exudes an alluring charm, while the patio seating provides a delightful ambiance for enjoying the pleasant warmth of summer and autumn days and nights.

Song Asian Cuisine
301 W Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

In a lively environment adorned with vibrant scarlet walls and cozy booths, an assortment of sushi and other delectable Chinese delicacies await. The exceptional Crab Rangoon served at this establishment is truly remarkable.

Kankakee Grille New Buffalo in the Four Winds Casino Resort
11111 Wilson Rd, New Buffalo, MI 49117

This relaxed restaurant inside the Four Winds offers everything from surf and turf to hamburgers and pizza. Enjoy the live performances at Kankakee Live! as well. The location of holiday parties is also very popular here.

The Stray Dog Bar and Grill
245 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

The Stray Dog Bar and Grill

Discover the Stray Dog T-shirt phenomenon! Whether you possess one or have caught sight of it, delve into the captivating realm of this iconic eatery. Indulge in delectable comfort food and experience firsthand the inviting ambiance that caters to families. Relish the ultimate culinary delights that New Buffalo proudly presents, including exquisite burgers, tacos, and pizza.

New Buffalo Bill’s Wood Fired BBQ – Forever Closed 603 E Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

Immerse yourself in the expertise of Bill Reynolds, the esteemed proprietor of this establishment. With unwavering confidence, he proclaims his mastery over the art of wood-fired BBQ, and his ability to flawlessly prepare ribs, brisket, and an array of barbecued delicacies only serves to validate his claim.

Villa Nova Pizzeria
134 E Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

Explore the Delights of Villa Nova Pizzeria: A Haven for Fans of Thin-Crust Pizza

Villa Nova Pizzeria deserves to take center stage on your culinary tour if you’re a die-hard fan of thin-crust pizza. The thin-crust pizza at this prestigious restaurant definitely steals the show, even though it also serves a variety of delicious sandwiches and traditional Italian entrees. Don’t pass up the chance to indulge in this culinary marvel.

Terrace Room in the Harbor Grand
111 W Water St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

Enjoy a pleasant experience of cozy fireplace dining while seeing the tranquil Lake Michigan waves. Enjoy a delicious selection of traditional Italian food that has been painstakingly prepared using ingredients that have been obtained locally and features the wonderful touch of handmade pasta.

Beachside Scoops – Permanently Closed
225 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

An all-inclusive ice cream parlor located on Whittaker Street, in close proximity to West Water Street. The shop is conveniently situated near the public beach and Oselka Marina, catering to both locals and visitors alike.

Copper Rock Steakhouse in the Four Winds Casino
11111 Wilson Rd, New Buffalo, MI 49117

This charming location, which is close to the Four Winds casino and is run and owned by the illustrious Pokagon Band of Potawatomi Indians, offers the perfect environment for a wonderful and private evening dinner.

Luisa’s Harbert Swedish Bakery
13698 Red Arrow Hwy, Harbert, MI 49115

Luisa’s Harbert Swedish Bakery

One of our greatest discoveries was coming across this genuine Swedish bakery and cafe in Harbert, which serves freshly baked coffee cakes, breads and sweet rolls, biscotti and kolachki, cookies and donuts, among other things. Do you really think there are options available without gluten? In fact, according to New Buffalo Explored, they are some of the top hosts in the area! They are also quite pleasant here!

David’s Delicatessen and Coffee
30 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

This cheerful location, a locals’ favorite, offers breakfast and lunch in addition to coffee, espresso, and freshly baked pastries. The menu frequently changes because they collaborate with nearby farmers to get fresh ingredients for their inventive cuisine.

Redamak’s
616 E Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

Redamak’s

Do not be deterred by the lengthy lines circling the structure. The lines move rather quickly, and those burgers and milkshakes are worth the wait. Any visit to New Buffs must include a stop at Redamak’s!